Another HIPAA Right of Access Settlement Ends in a Hefty Fine

Monica McCormack
Published: January 4, 2023•Last Updated: July 15, 2024•Read Time: 2 min

The HHS wasted no time in 2023, marking the new year with a fine announcement. On January 2, 2023, the HHS issued a press release announcing a $16,500 fine under the HIPAA right of access initiative.

Lab HIPAA Fine

Summary

Failure to provide timely access to medical records triggers OCR enforcement and monetary penalties. OCR enforces the 30 day access requirement, format and fee limits, and has resolved 43 right of access cases since 2019; recent enforcement included a $16,500 settlement with Life Hope Labs and two years of OCR monitoring after delays in fulfilling a records request.

Track and Manage Your Compliance
The Guard compliance dashboard
Unlock the Secrets to Effective Risk Assessments
Understanding and Applying Risk Assessment Procedures in Healthcare Compliance guide cover

Life Hope Labs Slapped with HIPAA Fine

In August 2021, the HHS received a complaint that Life Hope Labs failed to meet a medical records request. A deceased patient’s personal representative first requested access to her father’s records on July 7, 2021. Life Hope Labs failed to meet HIPAA right of access requirements by not meeting the request until February 16, 2022. 

Upon conclusion of an OCR investigation, it was determined that Life Hope Labs failed to provide timely access to the requested medical records, a potential violation of the HIPAA right of access provision. As a result, Life Hope Labs agreed to a $16,500 settlement and is subject to a corrective action plan, along with two years of OCR monitoring.

“Access to medical records, including lab results, empowers patients to better manage their health, communicate with their treatment teams, and adhere to their treatment plans. The HIPAA Privacy Rule gives individuals and personal representatives a right to timely access their medical records from all covered entities, including laboratories,” said OCR Director Melanie Fontes Rainer. “Laboratories covered by HIPAA must follow the law and ensure that they are responding timely to records access requests.”

Rated #1 on G2

“Compliancy Group makes a highly complex process easy to understand.”

G2 Best Software Logo

What is the HIPAA Right of Access?

In 2019, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) announced that it would prioritize HIPAA right of access enforcement. Since then, 43 cases have been resolved under the initiative. 

The HIPAA right of access standard requires healthcare organizations to meet a patient’s request to receive a copy of their medical records. These records must be provided to the patient, or their personal representative, within thirty days of the request (or within 60 days if an extension is applicable). Records must also be provided in the format the patient requests them in when it is reasonably appropriate to do so, and places limitations on the cost that can be charged for providing the records.

Under this standard, healthcare organizations must provide patients with access to all protected health information contained in their “designated record set.” 

There are two categories of information, however, that are expressly excluded from the right of access:

  • Psychotherapy notes of a mental healthcare provider documenting or analyzing the contents of a counseling session. These notes are maintained separately from the rest of the patient’s medical record. 
  • Information compiled in reasonable anticipation of, or for use in, a civil, criminal, or administrative action or proceeding.
HIPAA Trust Badge

Protect Against HIPAA Fines

Compliant organizations don’t get fined. Get started on your compliance program today!

About the Author

Director of Content Strategy

Monica McCormack has 5 years of experience as a compliance copywriter and editor. She is well-versed in a diverse range of compliance topics including HIPAA, OSHA, and state privacy laws. She specializes in simplifying regulatory compliance, making it easy to understand for a general audience.

Monica has a background in marketing and is responsible for creating all forms of written content, including articles, resources, press releases, and case studies. She also works with Compliancy Group's association partners to deliver educational content for members.