Physician Sentenced in Criminal HIPAA Violation

Monica McCormack
Published: August 25, 2020•Last Updated: July 15, 2024•Read Time: 2 min

Summary

Outside treatment, payment, or healthcare operations, disclose PHI only with prior written patient consent; otherwise share only de-identified research data, with all identifiers removed and no remote possibility of reidentification. In the Luthra case, unauthorized PHI disclosure and deceptive statements to HHS, including instructing a medical assistant to lie, were the basis for convictions for aiding and abetting unauthorized disclosure and obstructing a criminal investigation, with a one year probation sentence.

Track and Manage Your Compliance
The Guard compliance dashboard
Unlock the Secrets to Effective Risk Assessments
Understanding and Applying Risk Assessment Procedures in Healthcare Compliance guide cover
Criminal HIPAA Violation

Physician, Rita Luthra, has come under fire for a criminal HIPAA violation. The physician was sentenced to one year probation by the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts for her part in illegal drug kickbacks and healthcare fraud. 

Criminal HIPAA Violation: What Happened

During an investigation into Warner Chilcott, a pharmaceutical company that produces Actonel and Atelvia, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) interviewed Dr. Rita Luthra. The drug company hired Luthra as a spokesperson for Actonel and Atelvia, while she prescribed the drugs to her patients. 

Upon questioning, Luthra lied to investigators claiming that the company did not pay her for speaking engagements, but had paid her to produce a research paper on the drugs. She also instructed her Medical Assistant to lie to investigators on her behalf.

During her relationship with the drug company, not only was she accepting illegal kickbacks from the company, she was also disclosing her patient’s protected health information (PHI) to them without patient authorization. As such, she was convicted on two counts for the criminal HIPAA violation, and sentenced to one year probation for her part in the scheme.

The counts were:

  1. Aiding and abetting the unauthorized disclosure of protected health information; and
  2. Obstructing a criminal investigation by lying to investigators.

Disclosing Protected Health Information

When disclosing PHI outside of treatment, payment, or healthcare operations, you must receive prior written patient consent. The only exception to this is de-identified PHI for research purposes. For PHI to be considered “de-identified” all personal identifying information must be removed before the data is disclosed. If there is even a remote possibility that the information can be linked to a specific patient, the data is not sufficiently de-identified. 

About the Author

Director of Content Strategy

Monica McCormack has 5 years of experience as a compliance copywriter and editor. She is well-versed in a diverse range of compliance topics including HIPAA, OSHA, and state privacy laws. She specializes in simplifying regulatory compliance, making it easy to understand for a general audience.

Monica has a background in marketing and is responsible for creating all forms of written content, including articles, resources, press releases, and case studies. She also works with Compliancy Group's association partners to deliver educational content for members.