Six Risk Assessments Fail to Prevent $2.7 Million HIPAA Settlement

Monica McCormack
Published: July 21, 2016•Last Updated: July 15, 2024•Read Time: 2 min

Summary

Security risk assessments alone do not satisfy HIPAA compliance; organizations must document and implement a comprehensive program that includes administrative and privacy risk assessments, self-audits, remediation plans, written policies and procedures, employee training and attestation, document and version control, business associate oversight, and incident management. OCR has proposed a permanent random audit program to Congress, seeking rollout as early as 2017, which underscores rising enforcement risk.

Track and Manage Your Compliance
The Guard compliance dashboard
Unlock the Secrets to Effective Risk Assessments
Understanding and Applying Risk Assessment Procedures in Healthcare Compliance guide cover

Oregon Health and Science University (OHSU) reached a settlement with OCR earlier in July for $2.7 million. The organization had executed six risk analysis over the course of 10 years, but the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office for Civil Rights (OCR) found that those risk assessments did not constitute a sufficient HIPAA compliance plan.

This case should be a clear sign to healthcare professionals that merely performing a security risk analysis is not enough to protect their organizations from HIPAA violations.

HIPAA regulation specifically outlines a wide series of standards that organizations need to implement to maintain compliance. Security risk assessments are important tools that must be executed to find gaps in organizational security infrastructure. However, the law also explicitly states that Administrative and Privacy risk assessments are required.

And even these risk analyses alone still only address a small part of HIPAA regulatory compliance. For a total compliance solution, organizations need to be sure they’re also addressing self-audits (that includes the aforementioned security, administrative, and privacy risk assessments), remediation plans, policies and procedures, employee training and attestation, document and version control, business associate management, and incident management.

Breaches vs. Fines

OHSU had two data breaches that triggered the OCR investigation. The resulting $2.7 million fine, though, was not levied for the breaches themselves, but for the widespread institutional non-compliance that was uncovered over the course of the investigation.

In the end, organizations need to do all they can to mitigate breaches, but the odds of having a device stolen and having a data breach is roughly one in ten based on figures reported by Forbes. Preventative and security measures are important, but the over $12 million in fines that have been levied since the start of 2016 speak to the enforcement efforts that OCR is taking to punish HIPAA violations.

We’ve entered a new era for HIPAA enforcement, and all signs point toward it becoming even more severe as time goes on. OCR has proposed a permanent random audit program to congress that they want to begin rolling out as early as 2017. Non-compliance puts patient data at risk, and new enforcement trends mean that healthcare organizations are going to be more exposed to fines than ever before.

HIPAA Trust Badge

Protect Against HIPAA Fines

Compliant organizations don’t get fined. Get started on your compliance program today!

About the Author

Director of Content Strategy

Monica McCormack has 5 years of experience as a compliance copywriter and editor. She is well-versed in a diverse range of compliance topics including HIPAA, OSHA, and state privacy laws. She specializes in simplifying regulatory compliance, making it easy to understand for a general audience.

Monica has a background in marketing and is responsible for creating all forms of written content, including articles, resources, press releases, and case studies. She also works with Compliancy Group's association partners to deliver educational content for members.